Joe Scarborough
Morning Joe
Feb 19, 2013
Joe Scarborough conflates the rise of Rush Limbaugh and Fox News with the losses that the Republican have encountered in the past 6 election cycles.
These people energize the political base, but they also turn off the general population.
This descriptive comment demonstrates a "rational" ad populum appeal to the party to straighten out its idealogical and hardening political talk, if they want to win future elections. He is giving a middle and more moderate choice to the audience to join him in cleaning out the over-zealous voices. I find it instructive that he is throwing Rush Limbaugh and Fox News under the bus. And how does it relate to the other side--ie, MSNBC?
Looking for logic about our current cultural and political realities. I tend towards a moderate stance and bias. Currently i feel more persuaded by the moderate Democrat positions than liberal or conservative positions.
Tuesday, February 19, 2013
Art of Deception--Refutation of Ad Populum
Art of Deception--Refutation of Ad Populum
a continuation of previous readings
p 125
This is an overt appeal to the majority within the audience, done to squelch the voice of any minority or dissenting opinion.
By maintain the majority view, ideas like factionalism are minimized, thus bringing stability to the nation (attributed to James Madison in the Federalist Papers).
Another twist: expose something in the majority opinion that is just wrong.
This method is important when dealing with intellectuals and experts in the field because they are more likely to dissent.
I find this discussion fairly fascinating. I think that a group like the Republican minority leadership (very likely could come from either party, so I am not attacking only one side) have employed this strategy. They make a comment about President Obama being a socialist or communist. Parsing this we have ad hominem of name calling which is based on the ad populum bias toward capitalism. The allegation would require that the speakers would illustrate the capitalist value and ideal to counter-argue against the equality values of the dissenting view. To soften the blow they can concede to certain amount of social legislation as not to appear too Randian.
I can see how this strategy can appear both ethical and how it can fall into a fallacy. The approach, in order to work must promote a majority appeal. I see how both parties have employed the approach and how each has been targeted by it.
What I find even more interesting is the usage of visual arguments. The Republicans show the president playing golf while the country burns. The Democrats show the Republican courting the most selfish of capitalists. Devious and effective.
a continuation of previous readings
p 125
This is an overt appeal to the majority within the audience, done to squelch the voice of any minority or dissenting opinion.
By maintain the majority view, ideas like factionalism are minimized, thus bringing stability to the nation (attributed to James Madison in the Federalist Papers).
Another twist: expose something in the majority opinion that is just wrong.
This method is important when dealing with intellectuals and experts in the field because they are more likely to dissent.
I find this discussion fairly fascinating. I think that a group like the Republican minority leadership (very likely could come from either party, so I am not attacking only one side) have employed this strategy. They make a comment about President Obama being a socialist or communist. Parsing this we have ad hominem of name calling which is based on the ad populum bias toward capitalism. The allegation would require that the speakers would illustrate the capitalist value and ideal to counter-argue against the equality values of the dissenting view. To soften the blow they can concede to certain amount of social legislation as not to appear too Randian.
I can see how this strategy can appear both ethical and how it can fall into a fallacy. The approach, in order to work must promote a majority appeal. I see how both parties have employed the approach and how each has been targeted by it.
What I find even more interesting is the usage of visual arguments. The Republicans show the president playing golf while the country burns. The Democrats show the Republican courting the most selfish of capitalists. Devious and effective.
Labels:
ad hominem,
ad populum,
devious,
fallacy,
majority,
minority,
visuals
Monday, February 18, 2013
Art of Deception--Refutation of Authority
Capaldi and Smith, The Art of Deception
"Refutation of Authority", p 122
2 ways to refute: ad hominem attack or provide counter-authorities
6 types of ad hominem:
1. show the speaker as inconsistent
2. expose the speakers group where he aligned himself
3. discrepancies between theory and practice, as stated by the speaker
4. expose extreme abstractions as out of touch with reality
5. general attack against the expert concerning his expertise
6. your own experts. Any expert that disagrees with the speaker, even if they are not in line with your own
This discussion is quite instructive about the use of creative fallacy. These things are generally hostile towards a real argument, but rather undermine the message, any message, coming from an opponent.
It doesn't take much time to see this as a universal condition in the public discourse today. Take any public official.
"Refutation of Authority", p 122
2 ways to refute: ad hominem attack or provide counter-authorities
6 types of ad hominem:
1. show the speaker as inconsistent
2. expose the speakers group where he aligned himself
3. discrepancies between theory and practice, as stated by the speaker
4. expose extreme abstractions as out of touch with reality
5. general attack against the expert concerning his expertise
6. your own experts. Any expert that disagrees with the speaker, even if they are not in line with your own
This discussion is quite instructive about the use of creative fallacy. These things are generally hostile towards a real argument, but rather undermine the message, any message, coming from an opponent.
It doesn't take much time to see this as a universal condition in the public discourse today. Take any public official.
Labels:
ad hominem,
ad populum,
authority,
expert,
fallacy
Saturday, February 16, 2013
The Art of Deception (Refutation with Pathos)
Nicholas Capaldi and Miles Smith The Art of Deception
Refutation p117+
One of the ways to refute an argument is to expose it as absurd. This can be done by exposing factual information that has not been properly disclosed and respected. This must be applied both to the major premise and to sub-arguments.
An appeal to pity can be taken as a major premise.
Example: The President urges the Congress to vote about some aspects of gun control by focusing on the suffering of the victim's families. If this deflects from facts, it must be examined. A counter premise can be raised--the fear of persons who might be too vulnerable without firearm protection.
The danger is to make certain that all things really do connect. Otherwise the counter proposal is far worse than the initial one.
So assertions that rest on fear, sentimentality, pity, and other emotions (Pathos appeal) are an argument in and of themselves. When the President features the victim's family he is calling for a pity assertion. When the right counters with a disgust with that visuals of the President using children and conflating it with Naziism and then with a fear argument that the USA is turning int a fascist nation, their construct takes on a complex argument.
Is either emotion assertion correct? Can either be proven? Suppose the victim's family now wants guns for protection? Suppose the government has no intention of encroaching to the level of a Nazi regime? No wonder there is so much controversy. Logic is in need of some support.
I'd rather see this issue discussed on another level.
Refutation p117+
One of the ways to refute an argument is to expose it as absurd. This can be done by exposing factual information that has not been properly disclosed and respected. This must be applied both to the major premise and to sub-arguments.
An appeal to pity can be taken as a major premise.
Example: The President urges the Congress to vote about some aspects of gun control by focusing on the suffering of the victim's families. If this deflects from facts, it must be examined. A counter premise can be raised--the fear of persons who might be too vulnerable without firearm protection.
The danger is to make certain that all things really do connect. Otherwise the counter proposal is far worse than the initial one.
So assertions that rest on fear, sentimentality, pity, and other emotions (Pathos appeal) are an argument in and of themselves. When the President features the victim's family he is calling for a pity assertion. When the right counters with a disgust with that visuals of the President using children and conflating it with Naziism and then with a fear argument that the USA is turning int a fascist nation, their construct takes on a complex argument.
Is either emotion assertion correct? Can either be proven? Suppose the victim's family now wants guns for protection? Suppose the government has no intention of encroaching to the level of a Nazi regime? No wonder there is so much controversy. Logic is in need of some support.
I'd rather see this issue discussed on another level.
Labels:
abhorrence,
appeal,
argument,
fear,
gun control,
pathos,
pity,
premise
Friday, February 15, 2013
Predicate Logic
http://www.stumbleupon.com/su/25dJYR/www.youtube.com/watch?v=mLgp1pcMLDk/
Youtube segment introducing the field of predicate Logic
Jasoncampbell.org
Points:
theoretical constructions of predicate logic, but eliminating symbol discussions
first to view the actual propositions being presented, how to read it
start with definitions
1. individual constant................a subject term....always lower case with subscripts modified with variants
2. property or predicate term................upper case
3. proposition..............predicated term put with the subject term
Rumsfield has knowledge.
Rumsfield is the individual constant
knowledge is the property
Kr
The knowledge can remain the same and many different different individual constants can occur
can have two individuals
Kr, Ka, Kp add Alice and Patrick
Now use x in the place of the individual constant to indicate that various potential individuals can have this property.
Kx
This discussion goes a long way in explaining how name calling goes south in a hurry. For example:
All liberals are stupid.
Sl all? Sc, Slib, Sdem. Srep, etc. The argument is destroyed by the "all."
Youtube segment introducing the field of predicate Logic
Jasoncampbell.org
Points:
theoretical constructions of predicate logic, but eliminating symbol discussions
first to view the actual propositions being presented, how to read it
start with definitions
1. individual constant................a subject term....always lower case with subscripts modified with variants
2. property or predicate term................upper case
3. proposition..............predicated term put with the subject term
Rumsfield has knowledge.
Rumsfield is the individual constant
knowledge is the property
Kr
The knowledge can remain the same and many different different individual constants can occur
can have two individuals
Kr, Ka, Kp add Alice and Patrick
Now use x in the place of the individual constant to indicate that various potential individuals can have this property.
Kx
This discussion goes a long way in explaining how name calling goes south in a hurry. For example:
All liberals are stupid.
Sl all? Sc, Slib, Sdem. Srep, etc. The argument is destroyed by the "all."
Thursday, February 14, 2013
The Art of Deception p 27
The Art of Deception Capaldi and Smith, 2007
page 27
3 rules for examining logic:
1. We do not identify premises and conclusions by content.
2. We do not identify premises and conclusions by position or location within a paragraph. For stylistic or other reasons, the premises and conclusions can appear anywhere.
3. The appearance of the following word or words at the beginning of a sentence or clause signifies that the sentence of clause is a conclusion: therefore, thus, so, hence, consequently, accordingly, it follows that, as a result, I conclude, and other synonymous terms.
This leads a read to use a little wariness when listening to or reading the statements of other people. The actual meaningful concepts can very easily be hid in a portion of the text or speech where one usually does not pay so much attention. This explains the potential danger of a statement "why are you still beating your wife?".
A single word can have enough underlying flavor as to cloud the end conclusion, making it far more powerful or dangerous than the end statement.
page 27
3 rules for examining logic:
1. We do not identify premises and conclusions by content.
2. We do not identify premises and conclusions by position or location within a paragraph. For stylistic or other reasons, the premises and conclusions can appear anywhere.
3. The appearance of the following word or words at the beginning of a sentence or clause signifies that the sentence of clause is a conclusion: therefore, thus, so, hence, consequently, accordingly, it follows that, as a result, I conclude, and other synonymous terms.
This leads a read to use a little wariness when listening to or reading the statements of other people. The actual meaningful concepts can very easily be hid in a portion of the text or speech where one usually does not pay so much attention. This explains the potential danger of a statement "why are you still beating your wife?".
A single word can have enough underlying flavor as to cloud the end conclusion, making it far more powerful or dangerous than the end statement.
Tuesday, February 12, 2013
Divergent Thinking
http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_embedded&v=tnOnaKHZ3_k#!
Thomas Tallis
How many uses can you find for a paper clip?
The numbers go down as a person ages. Why?
Assertion: it's the schools because they teach there is only one answer.
Sounds like a beat up on schools concept. Use a little divergent thinking.
Critics condemn this particular argument, despite its common sense perspective. It sounds simple enough because people stop actively imaginative as they age, partly because of the imposition of reality upon their thought process, but the correlation to prove the accountability of the American education system is simply bizarre. Throwing sand into the air is not the cause of the wind.
What I particularly see:
If we can come up with hundreds of alternative uses for a paper clip, how does this make the world better? Divergent thinking, as valuable as it is, does not necessarily have enough direction to it to make it the primary learning method for the school system. Adults have a strong ability to dismiss useless mind trips.
The positive thing that I see in the argument is that men can let go of timeworn traditions followed only because they have never really been questioned.
Thomas Tallis
How many uses can you find for a paper clip?
The numbers go down as a person ages. Why?
Assertion: it's the schools because they teach there is only one answer.
Sounds like a beat up on schools concept. Use a little divergent thinking.
Critics condemn this particular argument, despite its common sense perspective. It sounds simple enough because people stop actively imaginative as they age, partly because of the imposition of reality upon their thought process, but the correlation to prove the accountability of the American education system is simply bizarre. Throwing sand into the air is not the cause of the wind.
What I particularly see:
If we can come up with hundreds of alternative uses for a paper clip, how does this make the world better? Divergent thinking, as valuable as it is, does not necessarily have enough direction to it to make it the primary learning method for the school system. Adults have a strong ability to dismiss useless mind trips.
The positive thing that I see in the argument is that men can let go of timeworn traditions followed only because they have never really been questioned.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)