Showing posts with label election. Show all posts
Showing posts with label election. Show all posts

Friday, September 28, 2012

Daryl Metcalfe on challenges to Voter Supression

http://www.economist.com/blogs/lexington/2012/09/art-voter-turnout


The art of voter turnout

If America had compulsory voting, would Democrats win every election?


Article in The Economist, Sept 28, 2012

Quote:  
It's not even debatable that certain individuals in society have an entitlement mentality, and think they should be allowed to enjoy the fruits of their neighbours' labours. If they are too lazy to do what they have to do to secure that ID, that is not the state's responsibility. The state can't fix lazy.

Context:  
Daryl Metcalfe serves as the prime sponsor of a bill in Pennsylvania to require certain types of ID in order to vote.  I do not know why the article is using British spellings.

The quote came in response to a question during a television interview.

Assertion:  not debatable that individuals have entitlement mentality.

Is it debatable?  What is debatable is his definition of the word entitlement.  Does he claim all social security and medicare payments as entitlements?  Are those elderly people and those who are sidelined for physical or mental disabilities guilty of wanting freebies?  The statement is clearly in need of a little qualification.  It goes after the ethics of the assertion he is making.  Is unemployment an entitlement?  What about other government programs?  By isolating some programs, maybe the public would agree with him.  Is a government subsidy to a business and entitlement?  The word is so problematic, that his assertion becomes meaningless because it is black and white fallacy in a ad hominem attack.

Assertion:  They (want) to enjoy the fruits of their neighbour's labours.  

This assertion is tied to the first assertion.  It drives the ad hominem even deeper.  So the elderly nursing home patient is enjoying her stay, especially since the neighbors are paying for it.  False cause and effect.  

Assertion:  They are to lazy to get ID.

Has name calling added to his use of ad hominem.  There are more reasons for a lack of an ID than laziness, although laziness could certainly be one of the reasons.  It could be elderly people born at home without a birth certificate, for instance.  It could be someone who doesn't know about rule changes because of a break down in educating the populace.  Are there already laws dealing with acceptable voter ID?  The allegation in the assertion is simplistic and does not spell out how it works.  It may be true, but it may be false.  It needs evidence.  Opinion over fact--needs fact checker.  

Assertion:  Not the state's responsibility.

I want to know what the state's responsibility is, according to Metcalfe.  

Assertion:  State can't fix lazy.

Has his argument really strayed this far?  He goes along a rambling path and ends up here?  

My Conclusions:

I doubt anyone would challenge the notion of someone misusing taxes by giving the revenue to lazy people.  The concept is definitely repugnant and reprehensible.  Mr. Metcalfe has done nothing to really prove his point that this is occuring--with voting.  He does not convince that the voter too lazy to get an ID.  Evidently that same lazy guy is motivated to vote, however.

I have no problem with presenting picture ID to vote, or to get on voting rolls.  The laws need to be fair and just, allowing for voters who have every right to vote.      Because of the complexity, legislators must demonstrate the need for certain requirements, and the appearance of trying to target certain voters is wrong, unless it is proven that they should not be there--for example, voter fraud.  This allegation against laziness stinks and does not belong in the discussion.

I think a careful reading and analysis of this kind of argument might actually help states, if they want to improve voter laws to discard the types of reforms that harm rather than fix the potential voter problems.  

Sunday, September 23, 2012

Tony Blair on Barak Obama

http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/richard-adams-blog/2010/sep/02/tony-blair-obama-mccain

"It's one of the oddest things about modern politics. The paradigm imposed, usually by a particular media view, completely disorients the proper analysis. I used to smile at the way the Obama/McCain election of 2008 was framed: Barack was the man of vision, John the old political hack. One seemed to call America to a new future, the other seemed a stale relic of the past. This was a paradigm that determined the mood and defined the election."

"Actually, it was John who was articulating a foreign policy that could be called wildly idealistic for the cause of freedom. Barack was the supreme master of communicating a brilliant vision, but he was a practitioner of realism, advocating a cautious approach based on reaching out, arriving at compromises and striking deals to reduce tension. For these purposes, leave alone who is right. It's just a really interesting feature of modern politics that the mood trumps the policy every time."


Assertion:  The media disorients the proper analysis of politics.

Mr Blair has a buried argument that the media manipulates the public, and his use of the word "mood" highlights the use of pathos in order to capitalize on modes of communication.  His assertion definitely expresses the futility of trying to get accuracy into an analysis, if it runs counter to the decisions made by the media, whoever that might prove to be. He illustrates his idea with the general labeling of Obama and McCain.  Mr Blair is probably advocating a correcting analysis by  someone to contrast with the ideas promulgated by media sources.

Assertion:  The paradigm used by the media defined the election (of Obama).

Mr Blair views the election of Barak Obama as the end effect of the American media to have him elected.  The voting public was cued to vote for Obama.

Assertion:  The mood trumps the policy every time.

The media follows a predictable path in the 2008 American election.  This "mood" called the results of the election, in the face of reality.  Mr Blair sees a twisting of the real Obama, the idealist, and McCain, the realist.  Does this mean that reality stands superior to idealism?  Blair has not really state which side he has chosen, but it seems to favor McCain's position.  This "mood" has taken the preference in the political paradigm?

My observations:

I still believe that the election of a Democrat in 2008 occurred more from a reaction than as an ideological shift in American voting.  Americans had grown so weary of the Bush era communications apparatus, that any change looked like an improvement.  Would this fit in with Blair's assertions"  Did the media decide we were tired of Bush and get the US to follow their lead?  If 2012 serves as a continuance of this paradigm, does it portend that the media has chosen Obama over Romney over similar biases and decisions.  How does Fox News fit in with this criticism?

I have grown quite skeptical of politics.  I find it difficult to accept credible sources for reference.  All too often the greatest messages of reality come from the third party candidates that have long had a hard time assuming any credibility, and who suffer permanent damage for even suggesting a need for alternative voices.  Has the public seriously considered Perot, Gritz, Paul, Jackson, Johnson, Anderson, and a host of othe?